Is It Worth Suing an Uninsured Driver?

Is It Worth Suing an Uninsured Driver?

Being involved in a car accident is always stressful, but discovering that the at-fault driver has no insurance can compound an already difficult situation. According to statistics, approximately one in seven drivers on American roads is uninsured, creating significant challenges for accident victims seeking compensation.

When you become the victim of an uninsured driver, you should demand all the compensation you deserve. Securing that compensation may prove challenging, so have a Missouri car accident lawyer represent you in the fight for justice.

Schedule A Free Consultation

How Prevalent Are Uninsured Drivers?

Uninsured drivers represent a persistent problem across the United States, though the rates vary significantly by region and demographic factors. Despite mandatory insurance laws in almost every state, millions of drivers continue to operate vehicles without proper coverage.

The statistics regarding uninsured drivers reveal the scope of this nationwide problem:

• Approximately 13 percent of motorists nationwide are uninsured
• Multiple states have rates exceeding 20 percent (meaning at least one in five drivers lack insurance)
• Economic downturns correlate with increases in uninsured drivers
• The financial impact costs insured drivers about $27 billion annually in higher premium payments
• Less than half of states require uninsured motorist coverage

These statistics highlight why encounters with uninsured drivers are relatively common, making it essential to understand your options if you’re involved in such an accident. The financial burden that uninsured drivers place on the insurance system and individual victims is substantial and growing.

Establishing Liability Against an Uninsured Driver

Before considering whether to sue an uninsured driver, you must establish that they were legally at fault for the accident. This is another critical responsibility your car accident lawyer will handle for you.

Your lawyer may prove that the uninsured driver caused your accident by securing the following:

• Evidence from the accident scene (photos, videos, physical damage)
• Police report documenting officer observations and fault determinations
• Witness statements from disinterested third parties
• Expert testimony when needed (accident reconstruction)
• Evidence of traffic violations or admissions of fault
• Electronic evidence (dash cams, traffic cameras, phone records)
• Medical evidence linking injuries directly to the accident

Establishing fault and liability is the foundation of any successful claim against an uninsured driver. Without strong evidence of fault, pursuing a lawsuit may not be worthwhile, regardless of the driver’s insurance status. Your attorney will typically conduct a thorough liability analysis before recommending legal action against an uninsured motorist.

Types of Damages Recoverable in an Uninsured Driver Lawsuit

When considering whether to sue an uninsured driver, understanding the full scope of potentially recoverable damages is essential. These damages fall into several categories, each representing different aspects of your losses.

Some of the damages your lawyer may include in your case are:

• Medical expenses (current and future)
• Lost income (earnings, earning capacity, bonuses, overtime pay, and other forms of income)
• Property damage and replacement of a totaled vehicle
• Non-economic damages (pain, suffering, emotional distress)
• Permanent disability or disfigurement
• Out-of-pocket expenses, such as transportation costs
• Punitive damages in cases of egregious behavior

These damages can be substantial, particularly when serious accidents result in permanent injuries or disabilities. However, the critical question is not just what damages you’re legally entitled to but whether you can actually collect them from an uninsured driver. This line between theoretical recovery and actual recovery is one your car accident lawyer will seek to cross for you.

Some Alternative Recovery Options Your Lawyer Might Pursue Before Suing

Before pursuing litigation against an uninsured driver, your lawyer will likely explore some less costly alternatives. These alternatives may provide more efficient and certain compensation than a direct lawsuit against an uninsured individual.

Some potential strategies your lawyer may consider are:

• Your uninsured motorist (UM) coverage
• Medical payments (MedPay) or Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits
• Health insurance for medical expenses
• Umbrella insurance policies
• Third-party claims against vehicle owners, employers, businesses, or other liable parties
• Workers’ compensation for work-related accidents

Suing an uninsured driver can make sense. However, this is likely not your only option. One of the benefits of hiring a lawyer is their ability to pursue many different strategies with equal effectiveness.

Your car acccident attorney will typically review all these options before recommending direct litigation against the uninsured motorist. Many cases are resolved through these alternative channels without ever filing a lawsuit against the at-fault driver. Even when accident survivors sue, their lawyers are often able to secure a fair settlement before having to go to trial.

Your Attorney Will Evaluate the Uninsured Driver’s Assets and Collectability

If your lawyer does not secure the settlement you deserve before filing a lawsuit, the next critical step is assessing whether the uninsured driver has sufficient assets or income to make a lawsuit financially worthwhile. This evaluation is essential in determining if a legal judgment would be collectable.

A thorough asset investigation may examine several potential sources of recovery, such as:

• Real estate ownership and property equity
• Financial assets (bank accounts, investments, retirement funds)
• Business ownership interests
• Valuable personal property (vehicles, boats, artwork)
• Income and employment stability for wage garnishment
• Inheritance prospects or trust fund access
• Fraudulent transfers of assets
• Bankruptcy filing history

This assessment is vital because obtaining a judgment is only the first step. Collecting on that judgment is often more challenging. If the uninsured driver has few assets and limited income, your ability to recover damages may be severely restricted, regardless of the judgment amount.

Your lawyer’s judgment and ability to evaluate resources will be key in helping you decide whether to sue an uninsured driver (or any other liable party).

Strategic Considerations in the Decision to Sue

Beyond the financial calculations, several strategic considerations should be considered when deciding whether to sue an uninsured driver. These considerations involve both practical and principle-based factors.

Important strategic factors to consider include:

• Statute of limitations deadlines
• Potential for the defendant’s financial improvement over time
• Judgment renewal options and collection periods
• Bankruptcy considerations
• Settlement potential once legal action begins
• Emotional benefits of pursuing accountability
• Possibility of uncovering previously unknown insurance or assets
• Leverage for negotiating payment arrangements

These strategic considerations may sometimes justify filing a lawsuit even when immediate financial recovery seems unlikely. Your car accident attorney can help weigh these factors against the costs and challenges of litigation to determine the most prudent course of action in your specific circumstances.

When Is Suing Likely Worth It?

Despite the challenges, certain scenarios make suing an uninsured driver a worthwhile pursuit. Identifying these situations can help guide your decision-making process.

Circumstances that typically justify suing an uninsured driver include:

• Serious injuries with substantial damages
• The uninsured driver has significant verifiable assets
• The driver has stable employment for wage garnishment
• Commercial vehicles or business-related activities are involved
• Other liable parties with insurance or assets
• Cases involving intentional or malicious conduct
• The defendant has professional licenses at stake
• The carrier providing uninsured motorist coverage requires you to file a suit before agreeing to pay

In these scenarios, litigation’s practical and strategic benefits often outweigh the costs and challenges. A thorough evaluation with an experienced attorney can help determine if your case falls into one of these categories where litigation is more likely to yield positive results.

When Might Suing Not Be Worth It?

Conversely, several scenarios typically make litigation against an uninsured driver impractical or financially inadvisable. Recognizing these situations can help avoid fruitless legal expenses and help you (and your lawyer) identify a more beneficial strategy.

Circumstances that generally make suing an uninsured driver impractical include:

• Minor accidents with limited damage and no injuries
• The uninsured driver has no assets and minimal income
• The driver is likely to file for bankruptcy
• Collection costs would exceed the potential recovery
• The accident is fully covered by your uninsured motorist coverage
• The driver cannot be located or has left the jurisdiction
• Liability is contested and difficult to prove
• The defendant is judgment-proof due to legal protections

In these situations, the practical challenges of collection may outweigh the theoretical value of a legal judgment. Your attorney may recommend focusing on alternative recovery sources rather than pursuing direct litigation against the uninsured driver.

The Potential Benefit of Uninsured Motorist Coverage After Your Accident

Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage represents one of the most effective protections against losses caused by uninsured drivers. Understanding how this coverage works is essential to evaluating your recovery options.

Key aspects of uninsured motorist coverage that accident victims should understand include:

• Coverage limits follow your policy selections and state minimums
• Includes both bodily injury and property damage components
• Requires prompt notification of potential claims
• Your insurer “steps into the shoes” of the uninsured driver by covering certain losses the uninsured driver causes
• Coverage extends to household family members and passengers
• Hit-and-run accidents qualify with proper reporting
• Generally covers medical expenses, lost earnings, and pain and suffering
• Typically doesn’t increase premiums if you weren’t at fault

Maintaining adequate uninsured motorist coverage represents the single most effective strategy for protecting yourself against the financial consequences of accidents with uninsured drivers. While this coverage adds a premium cost, it provides valuable peace of mind and practical protection against one of the most common driving risks.

If you have UM coverage, your attorney will explain whether you should access this coverage after the accident.

Legal Strategies if You Decide to Sue

If you determine that suing an uninsured driver is worth doing, your car accident attorney may use several strategies and tactics to position your case for success.

Potentially effective legal tactics and strategies when suing an uninsured driver include:

• Pre-filing asset investigations to identify collection sources
• Prejudgment attachments to secure assets
• Structured settlements with income-based payment plans
• Recording judgments as liens against real property
• Pursuing wage garnishment after judgment
• Conducting post-judgment debtor examinations
• Monitoring the defendant’s financial improvements over time
• Using license suspension leverage where legally applicable

These strategies require legal knowledge and persistent follow-through. Working with an attorney experienced in personal injury litigation and judgment collection provides the best chance of successful recovery against an uninsured driver.

If these strategies seem unfamiliar or confusing, don’t worry. An attorney will explain every strategy in terms that you can easily understand.

Uninsured Drivers Place a Massive Burden on Accident Victims. You’re Right to Hold Them Accountable.

Uninsured drivers create substantial burdens for those they injure, extending far beyond the immediate accident aftermath. These burdens can impact victims financially, emotionally, and physically.

Some of the unique challenges uninsured drivers can place on their victims are:

• Delayed medical treatment due to payment uncertainty
• Unreimbursed out-of-pocket expenses
• Higher insurance premiums despite not being at fault
• Time-consuming pursuit of alternative compensation
• Emotional stress during recovery
• Complex legal proceedings with uncertain collection outcomes
• Potential financial crisis or bankruptcy from medical bills
• Long-term economic consequences if compensation is never received

These burdens represent substantial injustices to accident victims who did nothing wrong beyond being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Some say that the insurance system penalizes responsible drivers who maintain proper insurance while allowing uninsured drivers to escape the financial consequences of their actions.

This fundamental unfairness motivates many victims to pursue litigation against uninsured drivers. Attorneys have no hesitation in suing uninsured drivers for the same reason.

Let an Attorney Hold an Uninsured Driver Responsible for the Harm They Have Caused You

The decision to sue an uninsured driver requires careful analysis of your situation. A methodical evaluation of collectability, alternative recovery sources, and strategic considerations will guide you toward the most advantageous approach.

Consult with an experienced personal injury attorney who can evaluate your case, including the collectability factor. Complete free consultations with auto accident attorneys serving your area, then hire the firm you are most comfortable with.

Schedule A Free Consultation